Scrum Masters: Why Influence Alone May Not Be Enough

TL;DR

Relying only on influence limits a Scrum Master's ability to drive real change, especially when teams or leaders resist Agile practices. Sustainable agility needs Scrum Masters who can enforce the framework, remove obstacles, and hold teams accountable, not just suggest improvements. Development managers should ensure Scrum Masters have enough authority to lead effectively, not just influence.

20 March 2025
Written by Martin Hinshelwood
1 minute read
Comments
Subscribe

The idea that Scrum Masters should lead only through influence sounds noble, but in many organisations, it’s also naive.

Influence works when teams and leadership are already aligned. But what happens when they’re not? When teams reject Agile principles, leadership prioritises control over agility, or dysfunction is deeply embedded?

At some point, persuasion isn’t enough. A Scrum Master must be able to remove blockers, challenge bad practices, and uphold Scrum, not just suggest improvements and hope for the best.

If your Scrum Master has no authority to enforce the framework, to say “No, we don’t work like that,” or to hold teams accountable, what’s the point?

Scrum isn’t about soft influence. It’s about creating real, sustainable agility. That requires leadership backed by action, not just good intentions.

Where does your organisation stand on this?

Smart Classifications

Each classification [Concepts, Categories, & Tags] was assigned using AI-powered semantic analysis and scored across relevance, depth, and alignment. Final decisions? Still human. Always traceable. Hover to see how it applies.

Comments
Subscribe

What to read next

Signal Scrum Leadership

No one questions a Product Owner authority

Explores why Product Owners’ authority is accepted while Scrum Masters’ is questioned, highlighting the need for clear authority to ensure …

Read article
Signal Scrum Leadership

Lack of Authority Blocks Progress on Critical Projects

Scrum Masters need authority to remove obstacles and drive project success. Without empowerment, they can't fulfil their role or be held …

Read article
Signal Scrum Leadership

Scrum Masters and Product Owners are held accountable for results

Explores the gap between accountability and authority for Scrum Masters and Product Owners, highlighting the need to empower roles …

Read article
Signal Scrum Technical Leadership

Overcoming Project Blockers and Challenging Organisational Inertia

Explores how lack of authority hinders teams from removing project blockers and overcoming organisational inertia, stressing the need for …

Read article
Video Scrum Leadership

Why the Scrum Master’s True Power Lies in Influence, Not Authority

Explains why a Scrum Master leads through influence, not authority, focusing on building trust, fostering team effectiveness, and supporting …

Watch video
Signal Scrum Technical Leadership

Scrum Masters: Enabling Teams, Fostering Agility, Removing Blockers

Explains the Scrum Master's role in ensuring team delivery by fostering agility, removing blockers, and being accountable for improving team …

Read article