What is a common mistake made by rookie agile consultants?
I think the most common mistake made by a rookie agile consultant is the belief that simply by following the rules or processes of whatever agile framework they recommend; positive results and outcomes will be achieved.
A belief that these practices and processes will solve any problems you may encounter.
Scrum is a great tool, but it is only a tool and not a solution in and of itself.
- People must want to use scrum; it can’t be imposed on them for it to succeed.
So, for an agile consultant to pick an agile framework for the team and insist that they use it will only create more problems in the environment.
If the only tool you have is a hammer, the tendency is to view every problem as a nail.
Agile consulting doesn’t work that way.
Every client environment is unique. Every application of scrum is unique. Every team you work with is unique. The context in which they operate is unique. The markets they serve are unique.
Dogma rather than empiricism.
The second most common mistake is the belief that the rules matter more than discovering the best way forward for the team.
Getting caught up in dogma and insisting people follow scrum by rote rather than deeply understanding what underpins those guidelines, and how to leverage that effectively to help your client achieve their goals and objectives.
-
Why is the client evaluating scrum as a potential option?
-
What are the challenges they face?
-
What are the goals and objectives for the organization?
-
What are the goals and objectives for the product development team?
-
Why are both entities failing to meet those goals and objectives?
-
What is the reason for the burning bridge? Why is change urgent and necessary?
-
What factors are driving the consideration of agile adoption?
And so forth.
So, I think that rookie agile consultants tend to focus on implementing scrum as a set of events that must be honoured and artefacts that must be integrated into their process rather than helping the team discover the underlying reasons why these events and artefacts exist.
Helping them to understand why scrum works the way it does, and how it can help them make more effective decisions and achieve their goals. How it informs product development and the creation of value throughout the value stream.
It starts with the basics. Empiricism.
Make things, work, intentions, and language transparent. Frequently inspect what you are doing and evaluate performance based on data and evidence. Adapt what you are doing based on what you have learned, what the data suggests, and on the feedback of customers and product development teams.
A sprint retrospective, for example, is a powerful event because it enables the team to reflect on what they have learned, what needs attention, and what needs to be actioned for the team to improve in the upcoming sprint.
Simply having a 4 hour meeting with the team and calling it a sprint retrospective doesn’t achieve the same outcome and the team will battle to understand the purpose of the meeting if you aren’t leveraging it properly.
So, going through the motions achieves very little, and that is what I see most often in failing scrum teams. People who are following the mechanics of scrum, but have very little understanding of why it matters, what the purpose of each event or artefact or accountability is, and how to use the agile framework effectively in pursuit of their unique goals and objectives.
A rookie agile consultant can walk you down the path and insist that you do everything the way the scrum guide tells you to, but a seasoned, skilled agile coach will coach and mentor you through each iteration and empower the team to improve in significant ways.
It’s the difference between the little league coach walking under 9’s through the rules of the game versus Pep Guardiola coaching a professional, elite football team to success in every competition they enter.
Those are the two most common mistakes I witness with rookie agile consultants.
About NKD Agility
Naked Agility is an #agile consultancy that specializes in #scrumtraining, #agilecoaching and #agileconsulting to help teams evolve, integrate, and continuously improve.
We recognize the positive impact that a happy AND inspired workforce can have on customer experience, and we actively help organizations to tap into the power of creative, collaborative, and high-performing teams that is unique to #agile and #scrum environments.
If you are interested in #agiletraining, visit https://nkdagility.com/training/
If you have identified the need for #agilecoaching and #agileconsulting, visit https://nkdagility.com/agile-consulting-coaching/
We would love to work with you.
#scrum #agile #scrumteam #agileprojectmanagement #agileproductdevelopment #projectmanagement #productdevelopment #agilecoach #agileconsultant #agiletraining #scrumtraining #scrumorg
Smart Classifications
Each classification [Concepts, Categories, & Tags] was assigned using AI-powered semantic analysis and scored across relevance, depth, and alignment. Final decisions? Still human. Always traceable. Hover to see how it applies.
What to read next
What is the hardest part of working with a brand-new scrum team?
The biggest challenge with new scrum teams is overcoming misconceptions about scrum and shifting focus from process mechanics to core agile …
In what circumstances is agile consulting appropriate?
Explains when agile consulting is best used, highlighting its role in building internal leadership, rapid problem-solving, and sustainable …
Navigating Client Needs: How Agile Consultants Can Uncover True Value Beyond Initial Requests
Explores how agile consultants identify clients' real needs, avoid common pitfalls, and deliver lasting value by looking beyond initial …
What are some big red flags when hiring an agile consultant?
Key warning signs when hiring an agile consultant include lack of community involvement, weak core agile knowledge, and consultancies …
Why did so many of the early agile transformations fail?
Early agile transformations often failed due to top-down decisions, lack of team involvement, and misalignment between leadership and those …
There is no "do agile" there is only "be agile"
Explores the difference between adopting agile practices superficially and truly embracing agile values, highlighting the need for deep …
Detecting agile theatre with real delivery signals
Why Most Companies Operating Models Fail in Dynamic Markets
A concise comparison of Predictive and Adaptive Operating Models, explaining why traditional structures fail in dynamic markets and how …
Don’t Manage Dependencies, Remove Them
Explains why dependencies are a sign of poor system design and outlines steps to eliminate them by aligning teams, clarifying ownership, and …
The Estimation Trap: How Tracking Accuracy Undermines Trust, Flow, and Value in Software Delivery
Tracking estimation accuracy in software delivery leads to mistrust, fear, and distorted behaviours. Focus on customer value, flow, and …
Flow of Value vs Flow of Work – Misnomer or Useful Shorthand?
Compares “flow of value” and “flow of work” in Kanban, explaining why only validated outcomes count as value and stressing the need for …
Why Outsourcing DevOps Fails, and How Real Engineering Excellence Starts With Your Team
Avoid DevOps vendor lock-in, discover how true engineering excellence starts with partnership, not outsourcing. Ready to transform your …
The Definition of Done is a Commitment to Quality
Defines the Definition of Done in Scrum as a clear, shared standard for quality, ensuring increments are releasable, transparent, and …
Why Your Definition of “Done” Is Holding Back Quality, Agility, and Trust, And How to Raise the Bar
Is your team’s “done” really done? Discover how a clear, objective definition of done boosts quality, agility, and trust in product …
Acceptance Criteria vs Definition of Done: Why Getting This Right Builds Trust and Delivers Quality Faster
Stop confusing acceptance criteria with definition of done, learn the crucial difference to boost quality, speed, and trust in your agile …
How to Evolve Your Definition of Done: Start Small, Grow Smarter, and Build Lasting Momentum
Unlock a smarter Definition of Done, start small, evolve standards, and build team momentum without overwhelm. Discover how progress drives …
Why Most Transformations Fail Without Honest Conversations
Most transformations fail without open, honest conversations that address real issues, making transparency and tough dialogue essential for …
Why Your Definition of Done Is the Secret Weapon for Real Business Impact and Agile Growth
Transform your definition of done into a strategic advantage, deliver real value, reduce risk, and drive business impact with every sprint.