A certification proves you’ve passed a test

TL;DR

Certification shows someone passed a test but does not prove they can handle real product challenges or make strategic decisions. Experience is a better indicator of true capability, though certifications can help identify knowledge gaps. Hiring managers should prioritize practical experience over credentials when evaluating candidates.

3 May 2025
Written by Martin Hinshelwood
1 minute read
Comments
Subscribe

A certification proves you’ve passed a test. It does not mean you can define a product vision, align stakeholders, or make tough trade-offs.

Hiring managers often use certifications as a filter, and while they serve as a minimum competency bar, they don’t guarantee expertise. I’ve met certified POs who struggle to influence stakeholders and uncertified POs who run circles around them.

Real competence comes from experience, making strategic product decisions, balancing customer needs with business goals, and driving incremental value. It’s about having the judgment to say no, not just prioritising whatever stakeholders demand.

That said, assessments like PSPO I and PSPO II can be useful for self-evaluation. If nothing else, they expose gaps in your knowledge. But if you’re relying on them as proof of capability, you’re missing the bigger picture.

What’s your take? Should hiring managers weigh experience over certification, or is there still value in the credential?

Smart Classifications

Each classification [Concepts, Categories, & Tags] was assigned using AI-powered semantic analysis and scored across relevance, depth, and alignment. Final decisions? Still human. Always traceable. Hover to see how it applies.

Comments
Subscribe

What to read next

Signal Product Development Technical Leadership

A two-day Scrum Master certification doesn’t make you a Scrum Master

Practical experience is essential for effective Scrum Masters; certification alone is insufficient. True expertise comes from guiding teams, …

Read article
Video Scrum

Overcoming the Ghost of Agile Certifications

Explores the limits of Agile certifications, emphasising real-world experience, continuous learning, and team validation over credentials …

Watch video
Video Scrum

Why Pursuing Agile Certifications is Your Key to Career Advancement

Explains how Agile certifications validate knowledge, support continuous learning, and help employers assess candidates, while emphasising …

Watch video
Signal Scrum Technical Leadership

Would you hire a Junior CISO? A Junior Financial Director

Scrum Masters require proven expertise, not entry-level skills. Hiring juniors in this role risks team performance and agile success; …

Read article
Signal Scrum Technical Leadership

Too many Scrum Masters believe they don’t need technical skills

Highlights the importance of technical knowledge for Scrum Masters, arguing that understanding team-specific skills is essential to …

Read article
Signal Scrum Technical Leadership

Hiring a Scrum Master is hard

Finding a skilled Scrum Master is challenging; true effectiveness requires deep Scrum knowledge, coaching ability, and alignment with your …

Read article